In a serious win for privateness and gun rights advocates, a U.S. District Courtroom has vacated an order that might have pressured the Second Modification Basis (SAF) handy over its membership checklist to the federal authorities.
The reversal got here after SAF, its associate organizations, and the Division of Justice filed a joint movement to amend the judgment late final week.
The Case: Reese v. ATF
The case in query, Reese v. ATF, challenges the federal legislation barring licensed firearm sellers from promoting or transferring handguns to adults below 21. Initially, the courtroom restricted reduction to people who have been members of the plaintiff organizations as of the submitting date and who resided inside the Fifth Circuit (Texas, Mississippi, and Louisiana).
The unique judgment went a step additional, ordering that plaintiffs “present to Defendants a verified checklist of their members as of November 6, 2020,” inside 21 days — a transfer that instantly raised alarms inside the gun rights neighborhood.
Privateness vs. Authorities Overreach
The Second Modification Basis and its companions made it clear from the outset: no membership information can be launched to the federal government, interval.
“We had no intention of releasing any personal membership information and have been ready to take all obligatory steps to make sure our member checklist was not disclosed,” mentioned Invoice Sack, SAF’s Director of Authorized Operations. “Fortunately, the courtroom responded to our joint movement promptly and vacated its unique order.”
With the order vacated and additional proceedings scheduled to find out the right scope of reduction, SAF expects extra updates within the close to future.
Standing Agency on Precept
The Second Modification Basis, joined by the Firearms Coverage Coalition, Louisiana Taking pictures Affiliation, and three particular person plaintiffs, is preventing not just for the rights of younger adults but additionally for the fitting of all People to help professional–Second Modification organizations with out concern of presidency reprisal.
“It’s preposterous to suppose we’d launch any kind of member information to anybody,” mentioned SAF founder and Govt Vice President Alan M. Gottlieb. “We’re grateful the courtroom noticed its error within the judgment and vacated the unique order. Nevertheless, we need to make it extraordinarily clear — we are going to by no means launch the personal information of SAF supporters to the federal government. That’s akin to letting the fox into the henhouse, and it’ll by no means occur.”
Why It Issues
This episode underscores a rising concern amongst gun homeowners and constitutional advocates: federal businesses are more and more demanding information that may very well be used to establish and goal law-abiding residents for exercising their rights.
Had the order stood, it could have set a chilling precedent — one that would discourage People from becoming a member of or donating to Second Modification organizations out of concern that their data may find yourself in authorities databases.
By standing agency, SAF not solely protected its personal members however reaffirmed a elementary American precept: the federal government has no enterprise conserving lists of residents who help constitutional rights.
The Second Modification Basis (saf.org) is the nation’s oldest and largest tax-exempt training, analysis, publishing and authorized motion group devoted to safeguarding and selling the elemental rights of people enshrined within the Second Modification of the US Structure. SAF engages in aggressive authorized motion to make sure the rules of armed self-defense, private liberty, and the possession of arms are defended, secured, and restored. By public training initiatives, SAF teaches the significance of the Second Modification to advertise a society that values and workouts the fitting to maintain and bear arms.
FRAC and Franklin Armory Rating Main Victory Towards ATF in Overreach Lawsuit
Blue State AGs Again ATF ‘Closing Guidelines’ Overreach
Senators Introduce Invoice to Cease ATF Overreach on Firearm Imports
