SIG P320 Problem—or Holster Setup Fail?

One other day, one other headline dragging the SIG P320 via the mud. This time, it’s the Washington State Felony Justice Coaching Fee banning the P320 from its academy attributable to considerations over unintended discharges. Recruits who have been issued the striker-fired SIG are actually being handed loaner weapons for firearms coaching.

Except you’ve been residing underneath a rock—or purposefully tuned out the noise—you’ve in all probability seen the P320 lawsuits, person complaints, and media blitzes. Contemplating the P320 is the U.S. navy’s commonplace sidearm and one of many top-selling pistols within the nation, controversy was inevitable.

However is it actually in regards to the gun? Or are we ignoring one thing greater?

Holster Mishap or Firearm Flaw?

Seattle’s KING-5 Information just lately coated an incident involving a sheriff’s deputy responding to a name involving an emotionally disturbed particular person. Throughout the takedown, a spherical discharged from the deputy’s holstered P320. No accidents, fortuitously.

However right here’s the place it will get bizarre: the company claimed the discharge was attributable to a free handcuff arm moving into the set off guard whereas nonetheless holstered.

You learn that proper.

The holster in query was fitted for a weapon-mounted mild, which inherently provides bulk and leaves a wider opening. That further room between the gun and the holster mouth? It’s an invite. Whether or not it’s a cuff arm, zipper pull, drawstring, or perhaps a suspect’s finger throughout a scuffle, you’ve now bought a transparent path to the set off.

We’re not taking a look at a design defect. We’re taking a look at a setup fail.

Too A lot Gear, Not Sufficient Thought

This isn’t an remoted challenge. Any fashionable striker-fired handgun will be weak in an improperly designed or overly spacious holster. The extra gear you strap onto a gun—lights, lasers, prolonged controls—the extra space you create for Murphy’s Regulation to strike.

Many departments jumped on the accent rail prepare with out contemplating the second- and third-order results. When requested why each officer wasn’t issued a weapon mild, one company responded, “Somebody’s going to make use of it to rummage round inside a automotive throughout a visitors cease… or to learn a driver’s license.”

Ridiculous, proper? Mistaken. It occurred.

The Weapon Mild Debate

Let’s be actual—weapon lights have a spot. However that place may not be each officer’s hip or each civilian’s hid carry rig. There’s a purpose many shooters nonetheless want a robust handheld for normal use: extra management, safer utilization, and no must muzzle-sweep every thing in your discipline of view simply to light up it.

Want a light-weight on a protracted gun? Completely. You’ve bought each fingers on the gun and wish constructive goal ID. However once more—self-discipline issues. A lightweight continues to be hooked up to a weapon. Deal with it accordingly.

The Larger Image: Setup Issues

This controversy shouldn’t be centered on SIG’s P320 alone. It ought to set off a critical dialog about holster design, gear choice, and retention concerns.

In case your present holster setup permits overseas objects—or physique elements—to succeed in the set off, that’s not a pistol drawback. That’s a coaching and tools drawback. Full cease.

Striker-fired handguns, together with the P320, GLOCKs, and numerous others, depend on correct dealing with, correct gear, and correct coaching.

Slap a light-weight on the entrance, use a loose-fitting or low-retention holster, then wrestle with a suspect? You’re asking for bother.

Last Ideas

Earlier than we pile on one other “dangerous gun” headline, let’s ask the more durable query: Are we anticipating an excessive amount of from our firearms and never sufficient from our setups?

Holsters have to be purpose-built for the precise gun-light combo you’re operating. They should shield the set off guard—interval. No excuses.

Blaming SIG alone for these incidents distracts from a wider challenge affecting all fashionable obligation and carry pistols. It’s not simply in regards to the gun.

It’s in regards to the complete system—gun, holster, gear, and person.